FutureQuest, Inc. FutureQuest, Inc. FutureQuest, Inc.

FutureQuest, Inc.
Go Back   FutureQuest Community > General Site Owner Support (All may read/respond) > E-Commerce
User Name
Password  Lost PW

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 12-29-2011, 03:11 AM   Postid: 180763
Matt
Site Owner
 
Matt's Avatar

Forum Notability:
671 pts: Dignified Competence!
[Post Feedback]
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Birmingham, AL, US
Posts: 1,231
Choosing a shopping cart

Today there are LOTS of excellent shopping cart solutions available to merchants big and small. Recent updates here in the forums are few and far between, so for the benefit of those looking here, here's the state of the E-commerce market at the end of 2011. I've included my own personal anecdotes, otherwise this is just a long list

PCI: It's real!
Times have changed since the carefree days of yesteryear. Merchants have to be concerned with PCI compliance and it can be a real headache. It's best to avoid PCI altogether. If you're using a 3rd party payment solution like PayPal or 2Checkout, congratulations, there's no need to worry about PCI. If you're using an Internet merchant account that processes payments on its own hosted page, then you're also "outside the scope of PCI" and have very little to worry about. If you're using a hosted shopping cart (shopping cart + hosting rolled into a monthly fee), then you also have little to worry about. For those daring merchants among you that insist upon hosting your own shopping cart and keeping the customer on your site for checkout, tread carefully!

Hosted solutions: carefree sales
Using a hosted solution (one where hosting + shopping cart + updates + support are rolled into a monthly package) eliminates much of the hassle of E-commerce. For a reasonable monthly fee, someone else has to worry about PCI-compliant hosting, PA-DSS application certification, and shopping cart updates. There are a number of players in this field, but some of the best known are BigCommerce, PinnacleCart, and Volusion. Although the monthly fees may seem high relative to a standard hosting account elsewhere, these hosted solutions are a real bargain if you're confronting PCI. Disadvantages of a hosted solution are generally: limited customization (you don't control the platform), more limited SEO ability (although sites can rank very well on these platforms, you may hit a ceiling, due to limited customization), and fixed feature set. These solutions can work very well for typical merchants and especially merchants that lack the time, budget, or expertise needed for a self-hosted option.

Among the hosted solutions, BigCommerce is what I recommend.

Self-Hosted solutions: commercial offerings
A self-hosted solution is one that you host on your own server / hosting account. Commercial offerings are typically more polished than open source / free offerings and are also a good option for merchants with limited time, budget, or expertise. Popular solutions in this area include Interspire's Shopping Cart (this is the software that powers BigCommerce), PinnacleCart, http://www.x-cart.com/, CS-Cart. and CRE Loaded. Don't let the marketing fool you, PinnacleCart is the only one of these that is PA-DSS certified.

If you're using Authorize.net, the only way to avoid PCI is to utilize the SIM or DPM payment methods. Of the above listed carts, the only one I know to have SIM integration is X-Cart. A 3rd party X-cart DPM payment module is also available. We are presently completing a DPM module for PinnacleCart, but nothing is officially available at the time this is posted. CRE Secure does offer a PCI-compliant hosted checkout for CS-Cart that may solve your PCI issue with Authorize.net.

Among the self-hosted solutions, CS-Cart has a lot going for it, although PinnacleCart is my preferred solution due to ease-of-use and auto-update mechanism (PM me if you would like a major pricebreak on PinnacleCart). If you're using Authorize.net and insist on a commercial solution, X-Cart is currently your only easy route to PCI compliance.

Self-Hosted solutions: open source offerings
Open source offerings have come a long way and there are numerous choices these days. There are the old standbys http://www.oscommerce.com/, osCMax, and http://www.zen-cart.com/. There are also several notable newcomers, namely Prestashop, OpenCart, and Magento.

Many of these support Authorize.net SIM. CRE Secure offers drop-in modules for osCommerce, Zen-Cart, and Magento, but can be branded for integration into most of the others.

Of this current crop, I'd avoid osCommerce and Zen Cart for security reasons. Although Magento is very popular among this group, I recommend choosing Interspire for a similar feature set, a straight up commercial license (Magento has a confused licensing model), and a smaller server footprint. OpenCart would be my recommendation for US-based merchants and Prestashop for merchants outside the states.

Other choices
There are a LOT of options I've left off, because they aren't mature, offer less than their more popular counterparts, or I haven't heard of them. I haven't, for example, included any .NET offerings. I also haven't included E-commerce plug-ins for WordPress or smaller PHP carts / checkout forms (not my area of expertise). One thing all of the above carts have in common is that they are designed for products or virtual products (e.g. eBooks). If you are marketing a service then there is an entirely separate batch of offerings (mostly targeted at Internet-related services), notably WHMCS, AWBS, HostBill, Plesk Billing, ClientExec, and Blesta. For online billing, Freshbooks is a hosted solution and Pancake is a self-hosted solution.

In closing, research your options and find a solution that meets your current needs. Too often merchants focus on the most feature-rich platform available and end up with a complex platform that they can never successfully manage, is too expensive to maintain, or gets compromised. Don't get too caught up in the initial sticker price. You need to focus on the long term costs (don't forget that open source solutions have maintenance costs that can easily exceed those of commercial offerings) and how extensively you will need to customize your solution (an area where open source offerings often excel).

Happy New Year Everyone!

-Matt
__________________
Webspace Creations
Matt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-30-2011, 07:01 PM   Postid: 180764
Melissa
Site Owner
 
Melissa's Avatar

Forum Notability:
0 pts: Even-handed
[Post Feedback]
 
Join Date: Oct 2000
Posts: 1,856
Re: Choosing a shopping cart

Thanks for taking the time to share your knowledge and recommendations, Matt. I'm sure this will help many. At the very least, it should give others a place to start in understanding what they need to consider.
Melissa is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-18-2012, 04:49 PM   Postid: 182195
Matt
Site Owner
 
Matt's Avatar

Forum Notability:
671 pts: Dignified Competence!
[Post Feedback]
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Birmingham, AL, US
Posts: 1,231
Re: Choosing a shopping cart

As an update (one year later), Interspire no longer offers their shopping cart as a downloadable product. They're heavily focused on growing the BigCommerce product and look to be getting out of selling scripts altogether and jumping into SaaS market with both feet.

As a correction to the original post, there is a third party DPM module for X-Cart that would eliminate PCI concerns. We also now have a 100% functional DPM module for CS-Cart and a 90% functional DPM module for PinnacleCart. If you are pursuing either of these (excellent) commercial PHP-based offerings, PM me for details on DPM module.

As a replacement for Interspire Cart, I'd recommend CS-Cart over Magento (100% code readability, less resource intensive, and ready for serious commerce out-of-the-box). CS-Cart also offers a FREE community edition that features most of the functionality included in the commercial version.

Happy Holidays Everyone!
-Matt
__________________
Webspace Creations
Matt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-22-2012, 12:15 AM   Postid: 182214
 Terra
CTO FutureQuest, Inc.
 
Terra's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 1998
Location: Z'ha'dum
Posts: 7,719
Re: Choosing a shopping cart

Thanks for the update Matt, there is some really great information in here...

Happy Holidays!
__________________
--
Terra
sysAdmin
FutureQuest, Inc.
http://www.FutureQuest.net
Terra is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 visitors)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:32 PM.


Running on vBulletin®
Copyright © 2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Hosted & Administrated by FutureQuest, Inc.
Images & content copyright © 1998-2014 FutureQuest, Inc.
FutureQuest, Inc.